FPG's Letters to A. L. Phelps




144. 1930:
Ottawa, Ont.    April 27, 1930


Still in bed, but somewhat less full of pains.

My dear A.L.P.,

There are still a few points untouched on. I've been thinking since I've been in bed.

(1) I don't think you can get $2500 for the cottage; but there is no harm in trying. I think you can get $2000.

(2) "Hell, I have neither a mission nor an ego," you say. Don't talk nonsense. Because you stand side by side with Kirk, you feel overshadowed.

Now listen here: there's a little world full of facts which is explorable and K. has explored an amazing fraction of it. But .

This plane world of facts is surrounded by a whole sphere of obscure and chaotic significances of which he knows nothing. I've tested him. He has never comprehended that there is an essential difference, let me say, between Baudelaire and Verlaine, beyond the differences in subject matter, technique, etc. etc. He is a most valuable chap; but he has very narrow limitations. That's why it's so easy for him to keep his world in order. But a world in order is necessarily an incomplete world.

Now yours is a wider world - a world which embraces chars. - an uncharted sea in which order will never prevail outside of an artificial creation - a work of art which consciously excludes perception of whole, vast, seething nebulas. You find it difficult to map out your share of the world of undefined significances. If you did not, it would argue your limitations.

"Why you should publish anything?" I'll tell you: because it is just now, more important that a consciousness of unexplored caverns be even hinted at than that a known world be mapped ever so accurately - you may deny that you can do that. I know that you can't help doing it whether you want to or not: provided you speak at all: for you, there is only one sin: to keep silent. Whether K. and I write a book more or less matters little; but it matters much, in this Canada, that, so far, you have no utterance in print.

Now will you be good? This is my carefully considered opinion: cleanse yourself of sin!

P.