BOOK FOUR: THE LEVEL
CHAPTER V:
MY PROBLEM DEFINES ITSELF AND I SOLVE IT

 HIS
is the last chapter of my wanderings.
Light gleamed ahead. My life-work was clearly outlined
in my mind. I had discovered the soil in which I could
grow. This book has nothing to do with that life-work itself;
it does not deal with the growth in that soil. Its topic
is the search and its end. I might stop here; I had found.
Unfortunately, and typically for the immigrant, a conspiracy
of circumstances seemed to arise, bent upon, and well capable
of, shaking the strongest faith of him whose wider outlook
was none too firmly established as yet. I was reconciled to America.
I was convinced that the American ideal was right; that
it meant a tremendous advance over anything which before
the war could reasonably be called the ideal of Europe.
A reconciliation of contradictory tendencies, a bridging
of the gulf between the classes was aimed at, in Europe,
at best by concessions from above, from condescension;
in America the fundamental rights
of those whom we may call the victims of civilization were
clearly seen and, in principle, acknowledged -- so I felt
-- by a majority of the people. Consequently the gulf existing
between the classes was more apparent than real; the gulf
was there, indeed; but it was there as a consequence of
an occasional vitiation of the system, not of the system
itself.
I might put it this way. In Europe the
city was the crown of the edifice of the state; the city
culminated in the court -- a republican country like France being no exception, for the bureaucracy took the place, there,
of the aristocracy in other countries. In America the
city was the mere agent of the
page 435
country -- necessary, but dependent upon
the country in every way -- politically, intellectually,
economically. Let
America beware
of the time when such a relation might be reversed: it
would become a mere bridgehead of Europe,
as in their social life some of its cities are even now.*
The real reason underlying this difference I believed
to be the fact that Europe,
as far as the essentials of life were concerned, was
a consumer; whereas America was
a producer. The masses were fed, in Europe,
from the cities; the masses were fed, in America,
from the country. Blessed is the nation that remains
rural in this respect, for it will inherit the world.
Freedom and happiness flee, unless "superest ager."
That was my idea; and it contained the germ of an error.
In my survey of the American attitude I was apt to take
ideals for facts, aspirations for achievements. From
the vantage-ground of retrospection, I can only be glad
that an anticlimax intervened before I set about building
my life.
When I came from Europe, I
came as an individual; when I settled down in America,
at the end of my wanderings, I was a social man. My view
of life, if now, at the end, I may use this word once
more, had been, in Europe,
historical, it had become, in America,
ethical. We come indeed from Hell and climb to Heaven;
the Golden Age stands at the never-attainable end of
history, not at Man's origins. Every step forward is
bound to be a compromise; right and wrong are inseparably
mixed; the best we can hope for is to make right prevail
more and more; to reduce wrong to a smaller and smaller
fraction of the whole till it reaches the vanishing point. Europe regards
the past; America regards the
future. America is an ideal
and as such has to be striven for; it has to be realized
in partial victories.**
*I must repeat that this book was, in all its essential
parts, written decades ago.
**I have since come to the conclusion that the
ideal as I saw and still see it has been abandoned
by the U.S.A. That is one
reason why I became and remained a Canadian.
page 436
When I walked back to Walloh, I had
two hundred dollars deposited to my name in the bank
of the town, and some little sum in my pocket besides.
I carried my bundle as I had done three months ago,
when I had walked the same road in the opposite direction.
Financially I was very nearly where I had been when
I had first landed at Montreal.
But then my only idea had been to make money; now
my one idea was to live and to help others to live.
Three months ago I had been a hobo;
now I adopted the disguise of one. I have since gone
out like that again, a good many times; I have always
enjoyed such holidays.
I reached Walloh late in the afternoon
and boarded an evening train going north. After a
ride of seventy or eighty miles I dropped off at
some junction and struck west again. For two or three
days I tramped it, alone. The crops stood in stooks;
I should find work at threshing.
Then I came to a town. As it chanced,
I hit upon a livery-stable, somewhere along the track.
The front of the building was occupied by a real-estate
broker's office.
I entered the stable and found the
hostler, a morose elderly man crippled with rheumatism.
"Any work around here?" I
enquired.
"Sure," he grumbled. "Might
pull the harness off that horse there." He stopped
at a stall, looking with helpless eyes at a long-legged
driver.
"I'll do that for you," I
replied, for he was bent double with suffering. When
I had finished, I turned and said, "But, you
know, that was not exactly the way I meant it."
Since I
had helped him, he softened. "I
guess not," he said with a sigh and went to
the front of the building.
I followed him.
"No," he answered my question
at last. "Not yet. They are through cutting,
and haven't started threshing. But in a few days,
I suppose. You see the boss."
"The livery man?" I
asked.
"Barn belongs to two lawyers," he
said. "Real estate
page 437
and farm loans,
too. They've got a big farm south of here, fifteen
miles out. Three thousand acres or so." "Where
can I find either one?" "Stick around," he replied. "One
of them will drop in before dark." In the dusk of the evening a small,
stout man appeared in the office in front of the stable.
I followed him in. "Have you any use for a harvest-hand?" I
enquired. He looked
me over. "I can use
some teamsters," he said. "Can you handle
horses?" "I can," I replied. "For
threshing?" "Yes;
but we won't start before next week. Meanwhile I
need a man to look after a bunch of horses here in
town if you are satisfied with the wages I offer." "How
much would that be?" "Well," he said, "I'll
pay you a dollar and a half a day. You will have to
board yourself. Not here. In the stable at my house.
You can sleep in the hayloft, if you want to. Meanwhile
you can haul hay for my drivers. When I take you out
to the farm, you get your board, of course, and the
current wages." "All right," I
said. And thus it was settled. I began work next day, hauling hay
from a nearby half-section of land owned by my employer.
There was a man living on the place, a Finn who spoke
only the most broken of English. Since he was getting
ready to move, I presumed him to be a renting tenant;
I was interested in his experience. My curiosity as
to the economic life of the immigrant settler led to
enquiries; and they disclosed a startling condition. This man had come to America five
or six years ago; he had brought a family which had
since increased by three or four members. This family
he had at first left behind in the city, while he himself
was drifting about. He had come to this town and started
to work for my present employer who, seeing his great
strength and his love of work, had treated him well,
had gained his confidence, and
page 438
finally had made him an offer which had
seemed good to the Finn. It had even seemed kind. The offer
was this. The lawyer would sell the Finn a half-section
of land at twenty dollars an acre, to be paid for
in half-crop payments. He would build a shack and
a stable for him at so-and-so much, and equip him
besides with all the machinery and the horses he
needed at stated prices. The machinery was second-hand;
I do not remember the sums involved; but I do remember
that the price as stipulated was what it had cost
when new. Of horses there had been five-good horses,
the Finn admitted; but colts, not broken or trained
for the work. The price of these was one thousand
dollars. For the whole of this equipment the Finn
had been induced to give five notes, lien-notes,
with that iniquitous clause, ". . . Or if the
party of the first part should consider this note
insecure, he shall have full power to declare this
and all other notes made by me in his favour due
and payable forthwith, and he may take possession
of the property and hold it until this note and all
other notes made by me are paid, or sell the said
property at public or private
sale; the proceeds thereof to be applied in reducing
the amount unpaid thereon; and the holder thereof,
notwithstanding such taking possession or sale, shall
thereafter have the right to proceed against me and
recover, and I agree to pay, the balance then found
to be due thereon." This, I
am aware, is perfectly within the law; it may even
work without hardship where "the
party of the second part" is fully aware of what
he signs, though I doubt it. This Finn was an intelligent
man; he could read and write his own language. But,
as far as English goes, he was to all intents and purposes
illiterate; through none of his fault. He had been
turned loose on American soil, equipped for the struggle
of life with nothing but an inherent trustfulness;
he was paying for his lesson with bankruptcy. My own,
comparatively trifling and mild experiences, annoying
as they had been, here widened out for the first time
into the experience of a whole class of
page 439
immigrants, and that the most desirable
one. In every nation there are sharks, of course; it
is only just to say that in later years I found the
worst of the sharks among successful immigrants. In
every nation there are brutes and fools; we cannot
charge their doings to the collective score. But children
need looking after; and the immigrant is, as far as
the ways of this country are concerned, no better than
a child. Here was a bona-fide settler, a prospective
citizen of the most promising kind, turned into a sower
of discontent. Do you blame him? Let me explain how the compact between
the lawyer and the Finn worked out. The lawyer played the part of the lumber-dealer,
the contractor, the implement-dealer, the horse-dealer,
the real estate agent, the collector, the bailiff.
At his disposal were willing friends and helpers; there
was, above all, the whole, inexorable, and irresistible
machinery of the law which he knew well how to handle.
With all these assistants, he stood arrayed against
a single man who was helpless because he did not even
know the language of the country. The lawyer made a profit on the lumber,
on the building, on the implements, on the horses,
and on the land; but he was not satisfied with that. If he had rented the land, he would
have had to furnish all that he had furnished the Finn,
free of charge; his only gain would have been the customary
half-share of the crop. It is true, he would have remained
the owner of the land and the equipment; but he also
would have had to pay the taxes on the property. As
it was, the Finn paid the taxes and the interest on
his debt for two years, in addition to two payments
on the capital involved. Then one of the horses fell; the machinery
-- which had not been new in the first place -- began
to go wrong at a critical time. When the third of the
notes fell due and he found himself unable to pay,
the bailiff seized machinery and live-stock. These
were offered at private
sale and readily found a buyer who proved to be the
second lawyer
page 440
of the little town, the seller's partner;
he paid a laughable price for the whole of the outfit
and shortly sold it back to the first owner at a profit,
but still at considerably less than the Finn had paid.
His profit was his part of the loot. The Firm still owed a considerable
balance; his equity in the farm and whatever he had
acquired in the first two years of his life as an independent
farmer -- two cows, some pigs, a flock of chickens,
the furniture in his shack, and so on -- came under
the hammer. The net result was that the Finn had worked
three years for nothing -- not as a renter would work
-- with an eye only to his advantage but as the owner
works, from sun to sun and longer, straining his powers
to the very limit. I might add right here that the same
farm was sold again, equipment and all, under exactly
the same conditions -- with the price of the land raised
to twenty-five dollars an acre -- before I even left
town, that is, within three or four weeks. My first impulse was, of course, to
leave then and there; but on second thought I decided.
otherwise. To leave would have been a weakness. If
at any future time I wanted to be of help, I had to
study just such cases. I saw even at the time that,
unless such problems are faced and the easy remedies
applied, nothing could come from the indiscriminate
admission of immigrants, but unmitigated evil. I might
add that most of the fashionable talk about Americanization
strikes me as mere cant. I know of no more effective
means towards that end than the open, frank,
unsugared square deal. With my new employer no such relation
was possible as had sprung up between Mr. Mackenzie and
myself. The farm was a matter of fifteen miles from
the town. Its lay-out resembled in a general way that
of the outlying camps on the Mackenzie place,
though, of course, things were on a smaller scale.
There were only twenty-five men in the crew; but in
the absence of the owners of the land -- which was
primarily held for speculation and disposed
page 441
of in parts as buyers were found -- there
was again that impersonal air about the work which
had characterized the organization on Mr. Mackenzie's
farm. I found the crew in a turmoil. When
I appeared, I was questioned about wages offered in
town. I was little interested in the amounts I was
making and could give no information on this point. The foreman asserted that the men were
getting what anybody else got in this neighbourhood.
But they demanded certainty. They were in a strange
isolation on the farm. They were kept busy throughout,
rain or shine; and the only way to get to town would
have been to ask the foreman to let them off from their
work for a day and to give them a ride to boot. They
were all of that type of men who, like the Swedes,
hang on to the work as long as they can, most of them
being Finns. I was most forcibly struck by the way
in which nationalities ran in streaks in this northern
harvest-migration of floating labour. At Mr. Mackenzie's
place the Swedes had predominated; here it was the
Finns. I had been on the place for two weeks
or so, driving a four-horse team with a load of wheat
to town in the morning and coming back late at night.
Then, one evening, the men held a secret meeting in
the horse-barn, and I was asked to come. When I entered,
I found them talking in a lively and excited way,
in Finnish, which I did not understand. What struck
me, however, right at the start, was the air of
mistrust, of suspicion with regard to the management
of the farm. Apparently the owners enjoyed a "hard name".
On the Mackenzie place
nobody had ever questioned the perfect fairness in
money-matters between men and owner. The wages had
been about twenty-five cents above those which other
farmers of the neighbourhood were paying; whenever
an advance took place, the foreman had made it known
at the breakfast table. Here it turned out that nobody
knew exactly what he was being credited with. All of
them had been engaged at "current
page 442
wages"; the foreman, when asked,
was evasive; he never stated a definite sum without
adding "I think" the last sum which he had
mentioned that way had been three and a half dollars
a day; but even that was no more than "he thought" they
were getting. The season was drawing towards its end;
none of these men had any particular reason to work
on this farm rather than on any other. There was no
consideration of loyalty involved. They were after
the greatest number of dollars in the shortest possible
time. As it happened, it was my turn next
morning to take the first load to town; my tank had
been filled just before quitting time at night. Under
these circumstances I would start before break of day
and reach town in time for feeding the horses; that
would leave me an hour or so for my own meal and for
whatever else I might wish to undertake. The men asked me to go to the station
at train-time, when farmers would be in, looking for
help, and to enquire about the wages paid elsewhere.
I promised to do so, and we dispersed. At the station next day three or four
farmers addressed me, offering work; an enquiry as
to the wages disclosed the fact that nobody offered
less than four dollars, while one of them offered four
and a quarter a day. It was about five o'clock in the afternoon
when I got home. As soon as I appeared on the road,
within sight of the crews, the whistle of the engine
blew for me to come out to the field and to reload
for the next morning. I turned on to the stubble and,
when I passed through the corner where the men were
loading sheaves, they crowded around me and asked for
the news. Everybody, as if by a concerted plan,
dropped his work and jumped into the box of my grain-tank.
It was thus, with a load of seething humanity, that
I reached the separator. The men at once called the foreman
aside and surrounded him, threatening. I heard the
foreman protesting, arguing, promising; and after a
short
page 443
time, while I was waiting for the grain
to begin pouring into my tank, the men dispersed, going
back to their work. The foreman came over to where I was
waiting. "Get out of that tank," he
shouted to me, his voice nearly drowned by the vibratory
pounding of engine and separator which were running
empty. "I'll give you your time," he
went on; "I'm going to town, you come along." I jumped
to the ground. "What's
wrong?" I asked. "No damned foreign agitators wanted
around," he shouted angrily. I shrugged my shoulders and walked
off to camp. When we reached the office in front
of the livery stable, the foreman and my employer held
a whispered conference. Then the lawyer went to a desk
and made out a cheque. I sat down and waited till he tossed
the pink slip across a small table at which I was sitting.
I looked at it and did some rapid mental arithmetic. "Just what do you call current
wages?" I asked. "What I pay the rest of my men," he
replied. "How much that is is none of your business.
You don't think that I pay current wages to a man who
quits before the work is finished, do you?" "Oh," I said with a shrug
of my shoulders and a smile, "that explains this
cheque." I crushed it into my pocket and rose. That was the end of my work as a harvest
hand. Now those were the years of tree-planting
in these parts. Every house in town was surrounded
by a yard with young plantations a few years old. It
had struck me that many of them needed attending to.
The tree used was box-elder, a bad choice in a windy
country, since it is apt to break in the crotch. I
still had my tree-saw and pruning knife; and somehow
I did not wish to leave the town just then. I went
out offering my services as a tree-pruner, charging
forty cents an hour, and finding an ample clientele. One day, a man who reminded me of the
senatorial Mr.
page 444
Warburton,
the manager of the veneer-mill in the little Indiana
town, had been watching me for some time at work and
at last addressed me. "You seem to know your business," he
said. "I have a large plantation at the north
end of the town. Do you care to look it over and see
what you can do with it?" "Certainly," I agreed. "I'll
go with you now." We came to an agreement on the basis
of my usual charge; I estimated that the work would
take me five or six days. I did not know the man; but an enquiry
brought out the fact that he was the partner of my
previous employer; a curious coincidence, I thought. I went to work with even more than
my usual vigour and alacrity; I was anxious to show
that I, at least, was willing to give a square deal
even though I had not received it at his partner's
hands. Frequently, while I was at work, the man would
come and look on, asking questions, making suggestions.
By dint of special efforts I managed to finish the
work in four days. On the morning of the fifth day I wrote
a bill for sixteen dollars and went to the law-office
to present it. A stenographer took the bill and asked
me to return in the afternoon. When I did so, she handed
me four dollars and stated that her employer had said
that was all my work was worth. I refused to take the money and asked
to see him; but he was not in. I went to his house, and he was not
there; nor could I find him anywhere else. A sullen
anger took possession of me; at him and his partner.
They were the lawyers in town; they were prominent
and respected citizens; but they were crooks, and I
longed to tell them so. To this very day I hope they will read
this record; if they do, they may rest assured that
I hoard their names in my memory. In the evening I was sitting at the
station, on the platform, talking with the section-boss
with whom I had
page 445
fallen in and to whom I told my experience
with the noble pair, when a tall, skinny man touched
me on the shoulder and gave me a sign to follow him.
He led the way to the side of the station-building. "I'm the chief?" he
said by way of introduction. "The chief?" I
asked blankly. "Yes," he said, uncovering
a badge on the edge of his vest. "The chief of
police. You better leave town; there are complaints
against you." "Complaints?" I asked. "Of
what nature?" "Never mind," he said and
turned to go. "You know. You can't go about here
and threaten respectable citizens. Take my advice and
clear out." With that he walked off. Then I returned to the section-boss
and told him of the new development. He, too,
laughed; but to my amazement he advised me to take
the hint and go. "Can't
beat politics in this country," he said. "But
what can they do except expose their own crooked
dealings?" "Railroad you on a trumped-up
charge," he replied. I mused for a while. When my first
anger had cooled, I decided that the advice was good.
What did it matter? I wanted to get out in any case.
After I had made the big change, then it would be time
to go after men like these. I had meanwhile seen enough
of America to put the incident
down for what it was: an incident. It no longer clouded
my whole horizon for me, as my experiences with Messrs. Hannan and Howard, Tinker and Wilbur had
done. I had simply run up against a pair that were
sailing close to the wind; I had hit upon another crooked
game; crooked games were no longer the world. The immigrant
always sees only a partial view; but I had seen enough
partial views to make their average more or less true
to reality. I even thought myself lucky to have run
up against this case; the very fact that I could take
it as I did seemed to prove that I was ready for the
work which I had chosen. If you run down a river in
a boat
page 446

and your boat brings up against a snag,
you do not get out to dam the river and to dislodge
the snag; you turn your boat and push it off into the
current; the snag is not the river, after all. As it happened,
the section-boss could offer me means to leave
town. He was shorthanded in his gang; that very
morning a man, after receiving his wages, quitted
work, leaving at his tool-shed a hand-car which
was needed further back along the line. The signal-posts
along the track were to be repainted before snow-up;
there was a week's work to be done, at a dollar
and seventy-five a day. If I cared to take the "job",
I could have it; he would get into communication
with the district-superintendent over the wire. Thus it came that my rambles ended
by a week in the open. I shot along the line of steel
at a speed which depended only on my endurance and
strength. There was fun in the work. Sometimes I wished
that one of my old friends in the capitals of Europe could
see me thus. Whenever I met a signal-post, I got off
my hand-car, armed with paint-pot and brush. At night
I made some station and stayed in town. To all whom
I met I was no longer a tramp or a hobo; I was a duly
labelled painter of signs for one of the great lines
on the American continent; as such I "belonged". For the first time in a year I thought
of young Ray; one day I
wrote to him to find out where he might be. I gave
the city of Winnipeg as my
address; for by now I felt that I wanted to become "repatriated" in Canada where
I had made my first fight for economic independence. At last the day came when I reported
at the office at Grand Forks,
handed over my car, and received my pay. I have mentioned a little notebook
which I had started to use soon after I had first set
out from New York. A few
years ago that little booklet was still at hand. It
held my accounts, among other things; and I remember
that, when I had received the wages earned on Mr. Mackenzie's
farm and left on deposit in the bank, the net result
of my
page 447
season's work as a harvest-hand showed
a saving of $249.35, on the day when I bought my ticket
for Winnipeg. When I arrived there, I had a number
of interviews. I wanted to go to foreign settlements
and help recent immigrants to build their partial views
of America into total views;
I wanted to assist them in realizing their promised
land. The upshot was that I applied for and obtained
a position as teacher.
I have been a teacher ever since; and
not only a teacher, but the doctor, lawyer, and business-agent
of all the immigrants in my various districts.
And twenty-seven years after the end of my rambles I
published the first of my few books.
THE END
|